Advice on Hardware for media vault and streaming

Damn, that is a “cool” solution hahaha. Thank you!

Out of curiosity, what could I expect from a data transfer rate assuming wired 1Gb network with the drives I’m using configed into RAIDZ2? And if a drive fails, what is the est time to rebuild?

With six drives worth of data to read/write to, you can expect to saturate the 1 GbE link when transferring large files.
Resilver could be a little under one day.

Great news on the speeds and Resilver. I’ve been doing some research and I’m starting to worry I’m getting in way over my head. It seems from my readings the QuickSYNC is a real nightmare with hardware which was mentioned earlier. Most seem to not get it to pass through the iGPU or dGPU correctly to transcode with PLEX. And the Scale seems to be heavy with manual coding to install, update, etc and VM’s which I’m not familiar with at all. I watched a video on Scale and setting up Plex and he was showing scripts to type in manually to get TrueNAS to install packets and update drivers etc. Yikes. I guess I assumed TrueNAS was more streamlined and user friendly with GUI’s. Am I missing something?

For the plex app on truenas you dont need to passthrough GPUs. You assign them during the plex setup.

Config of the plex app can be a bit annoying.
For example it seems that you need to enter the same path for “transcode” , “host” and “metadata”. Otherwise the plex app didnt see the movie library.

Also there seems to be a still unresolved issue, that the plex app grabs a random GPU if you have more than one.
During setup you assign “1 nvidia GPU” but you dont know which one that is.

I dont like the plex app.

Thats why I use plex inside a Win 10 VM. Super easy. Doubles as a gaming VM.

If you put it inside a linux VM it will be less resource hungry, but you will have to mount the movie folder otherwise plex cant access the library.
No such nonsense on windows, there u can point plex directly to a network share.

Thanks again for everyone’s comments!! So far it sounds like I have the following in hand or identified.

  1. Case: Silverstone Technology CS380B (temps questionable)
  2. HD: 8 X Seagate Enterprise Capacity 3.5 HDD
  3. GPU: Tesla P4 with 3D printed cooling solution

Need some ideas on the following:

  1. Motherboard
  2. CPU
  3. ECC RAM
  4. Power Supply
  5. Boot Drive
  6. ?

ECC RAM: Much preferably…

PSU: See the PSU sizing resource.

Boot: Anything small and cheap. Preferably a small M.2 NVMe drive in order to keep all 8 SATA ports on your motherboard for HDDs.

Whats your budget and what form factor for the motherboard are you preferring ?

Are you still gonna use your HBA for the discs ?
Are you planning to run VMs in the future ?

Do you want to buy new or used ?

Not too worried about budget. Unless it is several thousands… lol

I am willing to use SATA ports on a motherboard or HBA. Performance is key for me in general on this build. I’m sick of dealing with performance issues on my UnRAID build due to sacrifices. I would like the ability to run VM’s in the future. I would prefer to buy new as I’ve had issues in the past on used as I’m not a veteran and not sure who to buy from or what to look for when dealing with used.

Did you see this thread ?

The X10SDV-7TP4F looks great.

Your GPU will only be in a 8x slot, but i think bandwith should be plenty enough for transcoding.

That board does look great. Would want to verify the 8x slot wouldn’t limit my present and future though. Also the Xeon D-1537 seems hard to find! Found one on Sibbex but I’m not familiar with that seller. Crazy to think it is 9 years old already. Are there newer options that would be more readily available? I’m not opposed to this option, just looking at options.

So that board has 2 SFP+ transceivers? I’m not that familiar with it but you could use this PC to control another box of powered JBOD?

I think these are ethernet.

yup, did more research. Wouldn’t use those in my use case haha. Should have researched more before posting.

The board comes with the cpu. 1300$ on amazon…:scream:

After reading that thread on the X10SDV-7TP4F board, I’m wondering if I should be more focused on core (thread) speed versus core count? Also a user mentioned the board being VERY finicky with RAM. Is that common? I’m not a VM guy but i’ve always wanted to play with it. But I don’t want to be limited by single thread apps being limited by core speed. I was contemplating VM for BlueIris and others but it seems to be finicky. I want a good experience with storage read/write speeds and Plex predominantly with VM’s being a nice to have.

OP here from the linked thread

That surprised me as well. I asked around and searched in a few other places. I wasn’t able to find other examples of this happening. At the very least we have the compatibility list, but it seems like this was a 1-off.

All things being equal, you’d benefit from a higher clock speed in that case. But all things are never equal so it’s difficult to say how much 1.7 Ghz v. 2.2 Ghz would affect real-world SMB transfers (and whether you would really feel it).

If I wouldn’t feel it then I don’t really care. I see it like when a GPU review compares cards, one card is $500 with 60 FPS and the other is $800 with 63 FPS. You cant see the difference so why pay for it. But I’d pay the $300 more if it got me 80 FPS. may get another year out of it.

In this case it’s $400 for 2.2Ghz, $500 for 1.7Ghz. the benefit of the more expensive & the lower clockrate processor is: more cores & threads. Useful for handling multiple connections at the expense (tbd) of single threaded performance.

Understood and agree in that case for sure. In this situation it is $1300 for 8 cores versus $? for less cores but higher clockrate. Still trying to figure out what the other options are and could use some advice. In the case of a failure I’d have to pay another $1300 to replace both the board and cpu since it appears it is a package deal however unlikely. And is a Telsa P4 going to do what it needs to on a 8x PCI lane? Will it be limited in its full abilities?