5+ years ago I built a TrueNAS (then core, now scale) with the following components:
Fractal Design Node 304 - small 6 bay case
Supermicro X10SDV-4C±TLN4F-O - motherboard with 6 SATA ports & nvme port, 16GB RAM, 500GB NVME boot drive
6 x Western Digital 14TB WD Red Plus in a 3 x 2 wide mirror configuration - pool drives were originally 4TB and have been in-place upgraded since
The small case was chosen for the NAS previous location. We’re in a different house now with a dedicated server closet/space.
I’m looking for upgrade options - bigger case, more drives - the other components are fine for my current use case.
Thanks (?) to the AI boom, in-place upgrade to 24TB drives (for example) is prohibitively expensive.
I have an open PCI-E 3.0 X16 Slot on the motherboard.
I’m thinking of moving to a larger case with more bays, and adding a disk controller for additional drives. I’ve only used the motherboard SATA ports so I’m not sure what’s available / what to look for / price points. Any new drives will be added in mirrored pairs.
I could never get myself to ever do mirrored pairs. Just too much useable storage gone & as pools go, a failed mirrored vdev means the end of the pool where raidz has more flexibility. You get slightly better iops with multiple vdevs, but it’s all based on your value for your setup.
An in place drive replacement/upgrade might not be that bad considering you will have to account for all new replacement components including RAM plus storage, so you might end up paying more for a better capable system.
Do cost analysis spreadsheet between the two & make a determination if the extra cost if worth the extra capability of the new NAS. New isn’t always a requirement, so you might want to look into laterally more expansive setups. That way you can reuse RAM and your existing storage.
A new case might be all you need to add a 16i HBA card. Goes back to what are your needs.
Listing your end requirements or goals on how many drive bays you desire could help. Are you okay with a rack server style or were you trying to stay with a tower server? Is noise a concern as the servers with cooling setup for HBAs are usually noisy.
HBA cards usually recommend 150 to 200 LFPM (linear feet per minute) of air flow across the cards
For the controller, look at an IT-mode LSI/Broadcom card such as a SAS3008-based 9300-8i/16i or a 9207-8i rather than a RAID card; IT mode passes the disks straight through to TrueNAS. The 16i cards run hot, so choose a case that can put airflow directly over the HBA, and check that your PSU and backplane have the SATA power connections you need. In a dedicated closet, a large tower is usually simpler than rack gear unless you plan to add more servers.
9 bays would give me 2 more to build out my pool plus a spare. I have a couple of decommissioned 4TB WD Reds that would tide me over short term and I could upgrade to larger disks as money allowed.
Not interested in a rack configuration. I have more space but not THAT much more space. It’s ventilated space and in the basement so I think I’m good on cooling.
I don’t know much about SAS/HBA cards (I’ve only used motherboard SATA ports) but it looks like the 9207-8i or 9300-8i that @rachelrobinson references above would give me 8 more SATA ports via 2 4port breakout cables. Do I have that correct?
Open to case recommendations to hold 8+ drives - no rack server though. Hotplug bays (if they’re stable and don’t introduce random SATA disconnects) would be a nice feature. And I’m ok with something larger than a “NAS” case for better ventilation & airflow.
Correct on HBAs. Though this is 2026 and you may want to skip the 9200 series to focus on 9300, or even possibly 9400. If you go for -16i, go for a 9305 (not a 9300) or a 9400-16i (aka. Lenovo 430-16i).
You can mix drives on SATA ports and drives on HBA ports in the same pool.
Genuine hotplug bays usually come in server cases.
On the consumer side, Lian-Li PC-Q26 (10 drives) is a pleasure to work with, but no hotplug (no capacitors on backplanes) and… good luck finding one! If you’re not tired of taking multi-drive cages off to change a single drive, the Node 804 has good ventilation.
No idea how the 2*120 mm fans do with cooling the drives. The backplane covers only half of the height, but the fans seem somewhat far from the drives; the drive chamber would have to be well sealed on all sides to make sure that the fans actually pull air from the front and through the drives.
A step up maybe to a Node 804, enough room for 8 3.5 drives and options to place additional 2.5 drives as well.
The Define R5 is pretty spacious and has room for 8 3.5 and at least two 2.5 drives.
On here some documented his build of a NAS with a Jonsbo N3, which I thought was quite interesting and gives an idea what is like to set up a NAS with this type/brand.
Funny you mention being tired of taking multi-drive cages off. I AM tired of that. The node has been a great case but a PITA to work on. I don’t like disconnecting & reconnecting data/power any more than I have to on a stable system. I’ll skip the 804.
I don’t actually NEED hotplug (especially for the price a server case commands), but the specs for the Jonsbo N6 claim “server grade hotplug” and there are capacitors on the board.
I’m not above modding the case for better airflow if necessary - it’ll be in a storage room so I’m not bothered by aesthetics. HD temps in my Node 304 in that same space with 6 active drives average 35C.
I’ll check out the N3 build that @prez02 mentioned.
I have a somewhat custom open air frame case and max temps on my drive is about 36C. Just standard 120 & 140 mm fans sitting across the hdds. The HBA/NIC’s are about the same with a 120mm fan blowing across them. Nice thing with the open air frame, you just take it outside as it is and use an air hose to blow off the dust periodically.
I have use both Node 304 (X10SDV, 6z2) and Node 804 (D1541D4U-2T8R, 11z3) before moving everything to PC-Q26A/B, which helps reading cues.
On paper (or rather, screen), the N6 does not appear to have the same obvious cooling flaws as the previous N1 to N5, but I’m not thrilled by the PSU overhanging the motherboard.
Please report on the N6 if you go for it.
My modified A76 Lian Li case keeps the hard drives at or below 30*C, even if there is a multi-hour backup going. The supermicro fan script in turn keeps the case quiet whenever maximum air flow is not needed.
What I love about the a76 is the air flow and ease of work. But it’s very bulky compared to the utterly brilliant (but mini-itx only) q26 Lian Li, that is now unobtainable. For up to 11 drives, that is still the benchmark re: quiet, excellent air flow and build quality.
Neither is hot swap though like you I also consider hot swap only a nice to have in a SOHO setting.
I second looking for 9300 or later LSI HBAs due to the much lower heat production / power consumption. The smaller the case, the more difficult maintaining good air flows / cooling tends to get.
For general SOHO purposes, a Z2 would likely do you well re: storage efficiency. Rebuilding the pool would also allow you to optimize recordsize by dataset to speed up I/O if you haven’t done so already. But that also means at least one complete, known-good backup dataset.
Thanks. Photos may eb nice, but a report on drive cooling would be most interesting.
So we’re left with the last painful point…
The expansion plan by adding mirrors is sound, but an extra 2*4 TB will not being you very far, and once you’re at 4*(2*14 TB) you’re using 4 drives for parity in return for less usable space and lesser redundancy than an 8-wide raidz2—but also extra IOPS, that you probably do not need.
Even at the current 3*(2*14 TB), rebuilding to 6-wide raidz2 would give you extra redundancy and an extra 14 TB—10 TB more than the 2*4 TB mirror.
Admittedly this requires enough space for a full backup and possibly more 14 TB drives now, none of which comes free. But you will have enough ports for reshuffling data (extra drives temporarily hanging outside of the case are fine as long as you can wire and power them), and this could be a matter of “Buy cheap, buy twice”.