Immich experiences

HI all!

I am trying alternative photo server programs in a Truenas community VM, and got to Immich. So all I want, is to share my pictures with others. Probably the same reason most people want a program like this. And I am very interested in having the Machine learning functions.

Now I guess I am just being old here. But I really don’t think tossing thousands of my pictures in a program, not knowing where or how it stores them, is a good idea for organizing my pictures. And then having to make albums out of them again seems like double work. As my pictures are already sorted in folders. You could even call these folders; albums! Blasphemous thoughts maybe…

Unfortunately people dont seem to care about these things anymore. As most programs nowadays are based on the ‘I dont care where my pictures were or are, just toss them all on some big timeline and its probably gonna be fine’ formula.

Immich is one of the ‘toss’ programs. But they added the possibility to add existing folders. Great! Though it immediately feels like something they really don’t want you to use.

So I added the folders. Did the machine learning. Face recognition, smart search all work great! I like this. It works quite good. I happily show it to my family. Let them search and play. All good.

Then comes the kicker. You cant share a folder. You can only share an album. But you cant add a folder to an album. :open_mouth:

Ok I try to be clever. I go to the timeline, select a picture, click on select all. It selects everything. I add it to an album. Good. All the pictures from all my folders are now in 1 album that I can share. I share that album with a new user I created. I log in as that user. I can see the album! I hacked the matrix!

But.. There is no search field. :open_mouth: I cant use the face detection or smart search in a shared album!!! I had to google this to believe it. But its real. This is not a possibility. :open_mouth:

What is the use case for this program? To have pictures and machine learning functions all for yourself? Is not the biggest reason for these programs to exist, to share pictures with your friends and family? But they are not allowed to have some nice search options? face recognition?

So basically you make different users so they can have their own pictures. And their own albums and timeline. and their own faces. But not yours.

Ok. Very disappointed now. Then I will just upload all these bloody pictures again in a separate family user. I click on Upload. And now we come full circle with the folder hate. You cant upload a folder. Only a picture. So now i would have to open 4000 folders to select all the pictures in them.

This is where I quit. I love the program and respect the work that went into it. And the results I saw. But this just makes no sense for me. The folder thing. Ok. its not the fashion anymore. People are lazy. They dont sort their phone pictures. And they dont care where they physically are. I understand. They upload into a cloud like thing and people happy. Fine.

But if only upload, could just select a folder and it simply uploads all the pictures in it. And then just do the 'smack them on the timeline, and put them in whatever backend makes no sense for ever lost million directories. Fine.. Then it could have sort of worked for me. Computer sais no.

Can someone please just claud port the original synology photostation to linux and add the machine learning stuff to it? Then we are done. We old people would never need another photo program anymore. :smiley:

Truenas (iX) is not the develloper of immich. So feature requests would have to be posted in the immich forum.

But to answer one of your questions, i think the main goal of immich is to replace google photos for you and your family members living in the same household.

You can add other users from outside by letting them into your network using tailscale.

  1. Immich lets you keep your photos in their original directory structure: you just have to use the “external library” feature for this.
  2. I’m pretty sure there’s a 3rd-party tool out there somewhere that will set up albums in Immich using your directory structure.

Take a look at Immich Go. Depending on how you have your photos organized and how you want to handle them, this might be a solution for your initial import.

I used Immich Go to import my Google photos. It saved me a lot of trouble, one and done.

I tried Immich-Go too, but gave up on it. As I recall, it doesn’t work with external libraries: it insists on importing everything into Immich’s own library. Perhaps that’s changed. But I didn’t want that; I wanted to just keep all the photos in my own external libraries.

I wrote I used the external folders. And I also wrote I made and shared an album in the end.

But its still useless for me, as other users cant use the machine learning features on shared albums.

Machine learning features are not available on shared albums. So it kind of renders the sharing albums useless. And by that, makes the other users useless. Well, for my usecase.

In Immich it seems users are mostly just there to have their own picture database. The sharing is just a little extra side project. As sharing takes away Immich biggest features like machine learning.

Did you use the latest version of Immich? The partner-sharing feature was rolled out recently and makes big changes to how sharing works. Machine learning features seem to work fine on all my shared albums.

Big Immich User here.
The hole point of immich is to get away from the folder structure thinking and use the timeline more than folders while also being able to have timeline photos in “albums” so same image can be a part of multiple albums that you have created in the immich ui.
Yeah I was like you when i first started but I went folder by folder from my caveman folder structure and uploaded each of my albums into immich, all while i created “new” albums for each of the folders in immich, its time consuming but you only do this once.

and if you have made a proper storage template Storage Template | Immich

once you have all that figured out then the setup is a breeze to use
use ai to make the perfect config structure and you will get the structure on disk in truenas, easy as that.

then as dwolsten pointed out there is partner sharing, and there is external sharing.

the Shared people management was just added in the newest verison if looking at the roadmap Roadmap | Immich.