As to the other, unrelated problems of my system…
The Purple was pulled from the mirror because I was about to destroy that pool just as I expand the other one. It was vastly quicker not to re-cable the server and work on it twice to install a new drive and remove another one. I had this pool as a temporary solution anyway because the 10TB one was filled. I had two (mismatched) 4T drives so I installed them as mirror because I wanted to try how to set up that.
The HE10 is alone in the pool because I didn’t have money for a buddy for it. As far as I understand, RAID is mainly for availability, not for security. I don’t really need availabilty, but I need security, that’s why I had backup of the important data. (That’s a different question that losing that 2TB that I originally deemed not so important, would have been a pain, too. And this made me realize I might want at least one backup of everything.)
I definitely planned to mirror the pool in a couple of months, though. It’s just that right now I needed more space, not redundancy. So I bought the Barracuda to have 18 TB. I planned to add an 18TB disk as mirror (or 10+8 again, if that’s not possible).
BTW, we are speaking about a couple months of “risky setup”, the system was installed about 2 months ago. I deemed this time span accaptable risk for a datacenter drive that isn’t even used that much.
About the SMR drives. I know (something) about the CMR-SMR difference, but I didn’t pay that much attention to it. This setup doesn’t do much, really. The data on it is important but mostly archive data that I write once and rarely read (if at all). There is some R/W daily but not much, 1-10GB. In time, I certainly will find other things for it to do, I have some ideas. For this limited use, the lower write performance of the SMR drive didn’t seem to be a big compromise, given that it’s vastly-vastly cheaper.
Is there any other restriction of an SMR drive that I didn’t take into consideration? I can be convinced. If it’s really unfit for TrueNAS then I’ll put it instead in the small Zyxel NAS that I use for backup only.
EDIT: Protopia wrote before that resilvering takes a lot of time on an SMR drive. Is it the case of mirror as well? I don’t ever plan to use parity RAID, definitely not in this setup.