THe old de(HBA)te

Hey everyone,

I am in the need to switch from local SATA Ports on my MB to an HBA to increase my capacity by adding more drives.

Now, I rely on the proverbial “wisdom of the masses”. Which HBA should I choose?
LSI 9300-16i or LSI 9305-16i.

I have heard rumors (!) that the 9300 is not that reliable even when cooled, and therefor the 9305 is preferred, but from what I found out so far, some say this, others say that.

Is anyone so kind to weigh in on this?

Kind Regards

Raine

Whatever you find… but the 9300-16i can use more power than the PCIe slot provides(!) so it is seriously hot. 9305-16i is 16 W, 9400-16i (Lenovo 430-16i is often cheaper than the generic Broadcom part) is 12 W.

Do you need to go -16i?

id only buy ones already in IT/HBA firmware (or flash urself). raid firmware on those is a pain on truenas

9305-16i or the lenovo 430-16i rebrand is what id hunt used. cool the heatsink either way, the 9300-16i runs hot

I would not put any of those hot cards in my servers (low power, quiet).

Just get a supported NON RAID pcie SATA card. With enough bandwidth for your needs.

Any suggestions on that?

I have a 12 Bay NAS. When I would want to add cache or metadata SSD Drives via SATA…yeah, I don’t think an 8 port card would suffice.

for a 12 bay + a couple sata ssds for cache/metadata id stay off the hot 16i cards if noise/power matters

stuff that works for me on scale
-asm1166 based 6-port sata cards (often sold as “6 port sata pci-e”). grab 2 for the bays, leave mb ports for the ssds
-or one 9305-16i / lenovo 430-16i already flashed IT if u want one card for everything. stick a 40mm fan on the heatsink
-skip anything that still says IR/RAID in sas3flash -listall

check lanes on the slot too. a x4 card in a x1 slot will choke a full rebuild. paste lspci -nn | rg -i 'sas|sata|asmedia' if u want a sanity check b4 buying

L2ARC is rarely needed for home use, and SLOG even rarely. But if needed these would be best done by NVMe.

-8i HBA and motherboard ports should do.
A2SDi-H-TF or 8C-TLN4F provide 12 SATA ports without a HBA :wink:

Do as you want… but a 9300-8i, 9305 or 9400 is not that hot. 10G server-grade NICs come close to the same ball park.
Looking up the specs of SATA cards is a nigthmare. SAS HBA are the safe solution.

asm chipsets have been ok in my experience.

Again, no. Any RAID (asic based) card needs too much ventilation and power.
If we are using ZFS and want quiet reliability, a basic hba would do.

I have a refurbished iomega px12 with marvell chipsets that are pure hba, with SAS support. I put an extra resistance in series to quiet down the fans and now wish I would have bought a couple more of those when they were $300.

Nobody’s recommending RAID cards, and in fact everyone who knows anything about TrueNAS and ZFS is discouraging them in the strongest possible terms. What the knowledgeable folks are recommending are LSI/Avago/Broadcom SAS HBAs. And if you have enough drives to have a reason to be looking at one of them, the incremental power draw from the controller is negligible.

ASM 11xx are generally regarded as OK. Older ASM 10xx have mixed review with ZFS.
JMicron controllers are best avoided.

And definitively NO PORT MULTIPLIER, irrespective of controller.

Cheap SATA cards from Shenzhen may come without detailed specification. New cards from reputable brands come at least as expensive as a second-hand SAS HBA—which then lets you use SAS drives and/or add expanders for even more ports—and you may still not know in advance what exactly is on the PCB.

Here is a recent “near pool death experience” caused by a (StarTech branded!) “SATA card”:

Okay, first of all THANK YOU for all the recommendations and remarks.

To clarify: Power draw, ventilation and noise are NOT a problem. Like on of you said, I there is a need for 12 drives, the power requirements for the card are negligible compared to the drives. And yes, sooner or later, I will have the need. My wife is an avid photographer and therefor needs storage for her RAW files, I am a youtuber/let’s player and put an average of 40GB per week on that share, plus the audio production projects I archive… I currently have around 10TB of capacity (sadly with mixed size drives, 3x6TB and 1x8TB), but already I used up 6.1TB of that space, and that NAS was built just last year.

The NAS sits in a ventilated storage space (that is, whenever it’s not raining, I have the window open to let fresh air in) on the other side of the apartment behind three wooden doors, so noise is also not a problem.

So far, the LSI cards I mentioned seem to be okay by y’all, and I also looked into ASM11xx Chipsets, but sadly, all I can find are the 10xx chips that you said are icky and not 100% reliable with ZFS.

since I built this NAS on an old, shelved 4th gen i7 that was left when I upgraded my workhorse PC from said 4th Gen i7 to an AMD 5900X, I am unfortunately limited with PCIe slots. I only have PCI 3.0 and only one x16, one x8 and I think two x1 slots, and I plan on one day throw in a 10G card, so, thats why I would want a “one size fits all” 16i card in this.

I didn’t have the Lenovo 430-16i on my radar, I will have a look into this, since that one isn’t more expensive than a 9305.

Again, thanks for your recomendations. If you have some more that I didn#t think of yet, please let me know.

since your wife is a photographer (mine is too) what I would do is get a real server Supermicro dell etc. These servers have real active backplanes which can and are designed to support many drives, both SAS and SATA. Our main server has 16 drives and 82TB of usable space and 2 10GB ethernet ports and uses an older x10 Supermicro motherboard. The backup server is similar but older. I mention this because servers like this can be found rather cheap from reputable sources, and are still perfectly good and generally run Truenas without issues and you gain hot swap drives in most cases. You will likely have to stick a IT mode HBA in it. Also 10GB cards run really hot, at least as hot as the 16i cards and both need active cooling (fan attached to card). Good news is if you are using an active backplane then you don’t need a 16i card, 8i is fine. If you have Truenas already they can be nearly plug in drives and go.

Oh how I wish to have one of those, but over here in Europe, even second or third hand ones come at $1000 to $2000 (converted to USD), so that’s way beyond my budget. That’s the reason why I started a DIY NAS, so that I wouldn’t have to dig deep into my own pockets to get a NAS-ish thing up and running. Maybe in a few years, when prices have dropped, I will have something like that. But for now…
At least there are two redundant backups. If my NAS crashes, I will lose only around 3 days of work tops, which would be annoying, but manageable (which is not necessarily going to happen since I am not putting new stuff onto the NAS every day, but it could happen)

If you can’t go that route then at least get a fan for the LSI card to strap directly to the heatsink and if you add a 10GB card get one for it too if it does not already have one built in.

I have a Noctua 120mm left over…I hope it will get this card cooled down :smiley:
If not, I will buy a second of the CPU coolers I had for my gaming rig which is certified up to 240W TDP. If THAT doesn’t cool the card down, nothing can XD

That’s not what I see locally, but you may have to look for a refurbisher close to you.

The prices listed there are barebone prices. If you rack up RAM and CPU, you get close to my price range very quickly.

You can fasten a 40mm fan directly to the heatsink of almost every LSI HBA, and that’s enough to keep the temperature below 50°C (at worst…I have one that was 95°C without a fan, and 42°C with).

Joke’s on you, I don’t have 40, I only have 120s XD